Prime Rib vs. Ribeye: Which Should You Choose?

When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission with no extra cost to you.

When you go to a restaurant, do you order prime rib or rib-eye steak? There’s a big difference between these two cuts of beef. The best ways to prepare and serve the two meats vary significantly as well.

This article will explain the distinctions between ribeye and prime rib for anyone who has wondered what the two types of beef are like.

Prime Rib vs. Ribeye: What’s the Difference?

Even though it is often served as a “steak” or slice of meat in restaurants, prime rib is usually cooked as part of a larger roast called a “standing rib roast” and then cut into pieces. Even though overcooking this special-occasion cut would be a tragedy of epic proportions, prime rib is easier to make than it appears, so be sure to arm yourself with a meat thermometer or take the measures necessary to watch this roast until it is just perfect.

A ribeye is technically a steak since it is cut off from a prime rib roast (or standing rib roast) before it is cooked. Before becoming a lucky dish, a prime rib is always cooked as a roast, and a ribeye starts out as a steak. On the other hand, they are both derived from the same piece of meat.

In the United States, a cow is divided into eight sections called “primary cuts.” The rib primal cut, from which ribeyes and prime rib are taken, is found in the cow’s front quarter, up in the middle of its back, where the muscle doesn’t get much use and hence develops the desirable fatty marbling.

Since both prime rib and ribeye steak come from the same cut of beef, the only way to tell them apart in taste is by how they are cooked. Ribeyes taste better when they are quickly grilled over high heat, but prime ribs are more tender when they are first seared and then roasted at a lower temperature for a longer time.

Prime Rib vs. Ribeye: Which is Better?

Even though they come from the same part of the cow, they are cooked and eaten very differently. Grilling or searing a ribeye steak in a hot cast-iron pan brings forth its full flavor. For the best results, fry them immediately over high heat. Even though prime rib is usually cooked as a roast, the meat is usually seared to make a crust before it goes into the oven to cook slowly.

For prime rib, it takes time and attention to detail to cook well, making it more appropriate for a holiday meal with a large group of people; ribeyes, on the other hand, are ready in minutes and are more appropriate for a romantic dinner for two or a small BBQ. It’s important to remember that cooking technique makes a significant difference in the flavor of various cuts: Prime rib is typically more delicate because of the slow roasting process, although other people may prefer a seared steak because of its crisp and crackly char.

Do they have distinctive tastes?

There won’t be any huge flavor changes between the prime rib and the eye portion because they’re both similar cuts from the same area of the cow. Because of their high fat and protein content, they both taste incredibly meaty. Prime rib may have a modest flavor advantage over roast since it has more bone and fat. The bone-in ribeye, on the other hand, has a flavor profile not dissimilar to prime rib because of the bone’s contribution to the cooking process.

It’s in the preparation that the beef ribeye or prime rib takes on its most distinctive flavors. Most people like their ribeyes with just salt, pepper, and a reverse sear in olive oil, but those who want prime rib are more likely to try something different. The prime rib can be prepared in a variety of ways, ranging from the traditional broil to the more daring sous vide with natural juices.

What is the Texture Difference Between Prime Rib and Ribeye?

The muscle and fat content of ribeye and prime rib are similar because they are both cut from the same section of the cow. You won’t notice much of a difference in texture between these two cuts until you cook them, as those two criteria account for the vast majority of what makes a steak tender or chewy.

A rib roast and a rib eye will turn out differently depending on the preparation method you use. Various methods of cooking provide different textures in the mouth since they don’t sear the food the way a cast-iron skillet would. As an example, a roast cooked on the grill or in a pan will have a very different texture from one cooked in the oven or on a slow cooker.

Your beverage of choice can also have an effect. You won’t get the same effect from your steak as you would from a glass of red wine if you drank water instead. Molecules in red wine stick around in the mouth and help make meat more tender as you chew. Prime rib and ribeye can both benefit from this method to the same extent.

Prime Rib vs. Ribeye: Which is More Expensive?

Though the precise answer to this question will vary depending on the grocery store or butcher you visit, prime rib is usually the cut that requires a larger financial outlay, if only because the finished dish feeds more than one person and may include as many as seven ribs. Still, ribeyes are among the most expensive cuts of steak because of their exceptional flavor and tenderness.

Last update on 2024-04-04 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

What is a Prime Rib?

A prime steak comes from the largest section of the cow called the “prime” or “top” loin. Prime steaks are usually sold whole (bone-in) and trimmed of excess fat. They may be cooked rare, medium-rare, medium, well done, or blackened.

It’s called a “standing” roast because the bones run horizontally across the top of the meat.

How Do I Cook a Prime Rib?

Most of the time, you cook a prime rib at a low temperature for a long time, until the meat reaches a temperature of between 130 and 150 degrees Fahrenheit.

Most cooking methods require either a quick burst of hot air at the beginning to create a crust or a short searing stage at the end.

You can use a variety of different methods for roasting meat, including searing the outside first and then roasting it.

You might not be able to eat everything at once because this is a large cut. If that happens, we have a guide for reheating prime ribs.

What is a Ribeye Steak?

The ribeye steak comes from the longissimus dorsi muscle, which stretches from the sixth rib to the twelfth rib.

Longissimus dorsi muscles don’t need to be exercised because they’re not used for anything important. So their meat stays tender and has good marbling.

Sometimes you’ll see the rib eye called the Delmonico, after the famous New York City hotel; the cowboy cut, when it comes with the bones on; or the Spencer, if it has the bones taken out.

How Do I Cook a Ribeye Steak?

To cook a ribeye steak properly, use the reverse sear method.

  1. Turn on your oven and set it at around 275 degrees Fahrenheit.
  2. Put your ribeye into the oven and use your instant read thermometer to check its internal temperature until it reaches about 90-95 degrees Fahrenheit.
  3. As soon as your steak comes out of the oven, heat your pan so that it’s as hot as you can possibly get it.
  4. After your ribeye has reached a temperature of 90-95 degrees Fahrenheit (32-35 C), remove it from the oven and place it into a skillet with a small pat of unsalted butter.
  5. Sear both sides of each steak until they’re well-browned and then turn them regularly so that they develop a nice crispy outer layer and a juicy inner core.

Conclusion

Prime rib and ribeye may seem the same, but they are actually two very distinct cuts of beef.

Prime rib is a flavorful cut from a roast of ribs, and ribeye is a steak known for its rich marbling and buttery smoothness.

Now that you know the differences between them, you can order the right cut of beef at a steakhouse or cook it to perfection at home.