Is Costco Brisket Good? Our Test What To Know

When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission with no extra cost to you.

If you’re wondering if Costco brisket is worth your money, we’ve got the answers you need.

Did you know that Costco offers a range of cuts, including the whole packer, the flat, the point, and corned beef brisket? And they have three different grades: Prime, Choice, and Select, all USDA certified.

But what really matters is the quality. Is the marbling up to par? Is it well-trimmed and evenly cut?

In this article, we’ll put Costco brisket to the test and give you all the details you need to know before making a purchase.

Availability of Brisket Cuts at Costco

You can find a wide range of brisket cuts at Costco, including the whole packer, the flat, the point, and corned beef brisket. Costco offers a comprehensive selection of brisket cuts, catering to different needs and preferences.

However, the availability of cuts may vary, with fewer whole packer cuts and more points commonly found.

When it comes to the price comparison of brisket grades at Costco, they offer three different grades: Prime, Choice, and Select. Prime beef brisket, with excellent marbling, tends to be more expensive. Choice beef brisket is a mid-range option in terms of quality and price. Select beef brisket is a more affordable choice, although it may be considered lower quality.

Regardless of the grade, you can create a delicious beef brisket with any of them, but higher grades tend to be more tender, flavorful, and juicy.

Quality of Costco Brisket Grades

Consider the grade of beef brisket you prefer, as it will impact the tenderness, flavor, and juiciness of your meal. When it comes to the quality of Costco brisket, the marbling and fat content are essential factors to consider.

Here are three key points to keep in mind:

  1. Marbling: Costco offers three grades of brisket – Prime, Choice, and Select. Prime beef brisket has excellent marbling, which means it has more intramuscular fat throughout the meat. This marbling contributes to a richer flavor and increased tenderness.

  2. Fat Content: The fat content in brisket also affects its taste and texture. Prime brisket typically has a higher fat content, which can result in a more succulent and moist final product. Choice brisket has a moderate fat content, providing a balance between flavor and leanness. Select brisket has less fat, making it a leaner option but potentially less juicy.

  3. Personal Preference: The ideal level of marbling and fat content in Costco brisket will vary depending on your personal taste preferences. Some people prefer a fattier cut for maximum flavor and tenderness, while others may prefer a leaner option. Consider your desired balance of fat and flavor when selecting your brisket at Costco.

Smoking Brisket From Costco: Our Experience

Get ready to experience the mouthwatering results of smoking a high-quality brisket from Costco.

When it comes to taste, Costco brisket does not disappoint. The meat is flavorful, tender, and juicy, providing a satisfying eating experience. Costco offers briskets that are well-marbled and evenly cut, making them ideal for smoking.

The smoking techniques for Costco brisket are straightforward. Start by seasoning the brisket with your preferred rub, then smoke it low and slow for several hours until it reaches the desired internal temperature. The result is a beautifully smoked brisket with a rich, smoky flavor and a melt-in-your-mouth texture.

Whether you’re a seasoned pitmaster or a novice smoker, Costco brisket is a great choice for achieving delicious smoked meat. So fire up your smoker and get ready to savor the incredible taste of a Costco brisket.

Cost of Brisket at Costco: A Breakdown

When purchasing brisket at Costco, keep in mind that the cost can vary depending on the grade and is typically priced per pound. Here’s a breakdown of the brisket prices at Costco compared to other retailers:

  1. Costco vs. Butcher Shops:

    • Costco offers competitive prices on brisket compared to traditional butcher shops.
    • You can save money by purchasing brisket at Costco without compromising on quality.
    • The variety of cuts and grades available at Costco gives you more options to choose from.
  2. Costco vs. Grocery Stores:

    • Costco’s brisket prices are generally lower than those at standard grocery stores.
    • You can get more value for your money by purchasing brisket in bulk at Costco.
    • The quality and selection of brisket at Costco are comparable, if not better, than what you would find at a regular grocery store.
  3. Costco vs. Online Retailers:

    • Costco’s brisket prices are often more affordable compared to online retailers.
    • You can enjoy the convenience of shopping in-store and avoid shipping costs.
    • The availability of different cuts and grades at Costco gives you more flexibility in your purchase.

Overall, when it comes to brisket price comparison, Costco offers competitive prices compared to other retailers, making it a cost-effective choice for purchasing brisket.

Tips for Buying a Costco Brisket

To ensure the best selection, check the packaging date on the brisket and choose the freshest option available.

When buying a Costco brisket, freshness is crucial. Most Costco briskets are packaged in Cryovac, which helps seal in the freshness and preserve the quality of the meat. Take a look at the packaging date on the brisket to ensure that you are getting the freshest option.

Additionally, consider the weight range of the brisket. Briskets weighing between 14-16 pounds are generally recommended for even cooking. However, if your smoker allows, larger sizes can also be accommodated.

Keep these factors in mind when purchasing a Costco brisket to ensure that you are getting the best quality and size for your cooking needs.

Individual Preferences and Costco Brisket

Now that you have some tips for buying a brisket at Costco, it’s time to consider your personal preferences when it comes to the taste of the brisket. Everyone has their own idea of what makes a good brisket, and Costco offers a variety of options to cater to different tastes. Here are a few things to keep in mind:

  1. Taste: The taste of Costco brisket can vary depending on the grade and marbling. Prime beef brisket tends to have excellent marbling, resulting in a richer and more flavorful taste. Choice beef brisket offers a good balance between flavor and price. Select beef brisket, while more affordable, may have less marbling and could be considered slightly less flavorful.

  2. Tenderness: Higher grades of brisket, such as Prime, are known to be more tender due to the increased marbling. However, even Select beef brisket can be cooked to be tender and delicious with the right techniques.

  3. Personal Preferences: Ultimately, personal preferences play a significant role in determining whether Costco brisket meets your expectations. Some individuals may find Costco brisket to be exceptional in taste and tenderness, while others may have different expectations or preferences. It’s important to consider your own taste preferences when choosing a brisket at Costco.

Considerations for Quantity and Cooking Techniques

If you’re planning to serve a large crowd, it’s important to consider the quantity of meat needed and choose a size that can accommodate your requirements. When it comes to Costco brisket, you have options to suit your needs.

Whether you’re looking for the whole packer, the flat, the point, or even corned beef brisket, Costco offers a variety of cuts to fulfill your specific requirements. The availability of cuts may vary, but you can find any cut of brisket at Costco.

When it comes to cooking techniques, smoking brisket is a popular choice. Costco briskets meet the criteria for smoking, with good marbling, even trimming, and a decent size for consistent cooking.

Additionally, the prices at Costco for different grades of brisket vary, so you can choose the quality that fits your budget. Consider the quantity of meat needed and compare cooking techniques to make the best choice for your next gathering.


After conducting our test, we can confidently say that Costco brisket is a top-notch choice for all your smoking needs. The availability of different cuts, such as the whole packer and the point, ensures that you can find the perfect brisket for your preference.

The quality of brisket at Costco is exceptional, with USDA-certified Prime, Choice, and Select grades available. The marbling, fat content, and distribution are all on point, ensuring a juicy and flavorful end result.

The cost of brisket at Costco is reasonable, considering the quality you get. When buying a brisket, be sure to consider factors like freshness, weight range, and fat cap.

Whether you’re a seasoned pitmaster or just starting out, Costco brisket is a reliable choice. So head to your nearest Costco and get ready to enjoy a mouthwatering, perfectly smoked brisket that will have everyone asking for seconds.